A tiny bit old Windows got right
One thing I really admired in earlier versions of Windows was the thing that was also its weak point: the keyboard orientation.
I miss the old tradition in Windows where many commands had underlined letters, and you could simply press Alt and that letter to jump to it:
If I remember correctly, eventually this got simplified so that the underlines were only there when you held Alt (although I bet there was an option to keep showing it all the time).
Opening Windows 11 today, it feels like the system got less elegant. I can still press Alt and stuff happens, but it doesn’t look nearly as good or tightly integrated, and the two alternate entry points (Alt and the keyboard shortcuts) become muddled:
In the meantime, on a Mac, in various places apps reinvent the wheel by their own thing.
I just saw this in Nova, the code editor, which is very thoughtful; those shortcuts only exist within this dialog (and one wonders if they couldn’t just be letters without modifiers)?
A little more old-fashioned from Photoshop, and the same question: could they just not be digits, without requiring ⌥?
Previously, I mentioned yet another idea from DevonThink.
I appreciate these gestures toward moving faster via a keyboard, but I wonder if we lost something that already used to work well in old Windows.