Newsletter
  • Get a newsletter digest every Friday:
Contact

Send me feedback, tips, bug reports, and anything else:

About me and the blog

My name is Marcin Wichary (he/him). I’ve worked as a UX designer, typographer, front-end person, and manager at Google, Medium, and Figma. I’ve also written a book about keyboards and typing, gave talks, and published essays about design, typography, and technology.

Unsung is my blog about software craft and quality.

More info about Unsung

Send me feedback, tips, bug reports, and anything else:

More info about Unsung

iOS’s unpredictable search

This is what happens when I search for “access” in my iPhone’s settings:

Every time, the results appear in a different order. Here are all the I’m-done-typing states from the above video:

There are a few reasons this might be happening, and to be honest I don’t fully understand how they got there.

But one idea might be something I’ve seen a few times in my career that’s worth knowing about. It’s possible that at some point in the search chain… nothing takes care of reordering the items. They are found, they are filtered properly for the query, but then no algorithm ranks them – or, they are all ranked with the same value, and within that value, whatever random order they arrived in becomes what’s shown to the user.

The consequence is that the results are not deterministic, but I believe they should be.

I know search is more of a “living, breathing organism” compared to other stable navigation mechanisms – but it’s still useful for the user to match things consistently, and rely on certain things being repeatable. Even if you don’t understand the algorithm, you can learn that a certain result always matches on the first, second, or third location. This might change once in a while as the search evolves, but it’s better than nothing.

The extra challenge in this particular case is that settings are already scary – even recently, we’ve seen some extra paranoia where a chunk of the public, likely further frightened by the new AirPods listening feature, started spreading videos prompting people to toggle off an iOS setting they didn’t really understand.

“Access” is a harder query, so here’s another example. You would imagine typing “accessibility” would show you the main accessibility settings as the first result, every single time. Yet, here it’s the same inconsistent story:

Even Google search, where the results truly change all the time, seems to be more deterministic.

And, speaking of! Android doesn’t have the same problem:

Sorry about the accidental Uber Eats promo.