“It was awful, it was too sim-y.”
The original Grand Theft Auto – known in early production as Race ’n’ Chase – had a problem: it just wasn’t too fun to play. The driving was there, the buildings were there, the missions were there, but the joy wasn’t.
What injected the right amount of joy was… an unexpected bug.
When the player earned a “wanted” status, the game dispatched some cop cars to chase them. As they do, the cop cars had a particular pathfinding algorithm where they meant to converge on a player. But within that algorithm, there was a mistake, as described by one of the game’s creators:
[…] the other thing that was a problem was the handling – the car handling was appalling. There was a point in it where you used to have a button for opening the doors and it was just rubbish. I can’t remember if this is true because we used to joke about it that you even had to start the engine. It was awful, it was too sim-y.
And there was a whole living city thing that crept into it. That kind of inspires people to be more realistic and simulate more often. That steers you in a certain direction.
But there were people on the team constantly trying to get that fixed. So the core of playing was fundamentally broke. There were steps being taken to fix that, but it wasn’t really gelling together. The police behaved really badly, the way they originally worked was just rubbish.
Then one day, I think it was a bug, the police suddenly became mental and aggressive. It was because they were trying to drive through you. Their route finding was screwed I think and that was an awesome moment because suddenly the real drama where, “Oh my God, the police are psycho – they’re trying to ram me off the road.”
That was awesome, so that stayed in. It was tweaked a little bit, but that stayed in because that was great fun. Suddenly the game got more dramatic and it’s no longer boring – the police trying to pull you over. They’re after you, they’re trying to ram you off the fucking road. Everybody suddenly went, “Hey, this is actually pretty cool. There’s something in this, this is working.”
It was less about the mission stuff, which we always thought was another mess, and more about just general play – just being able to piss around.
I don’t think we’ve ever seen the code or the bug in question. I found the story interesting, not only because it teaches us that you can’t really work your way around bad mechanics (this can be as true for serious apps as it is for videogames), but also because it highlights the interesting push and pull between realism and fun.
The game was eventually released in 1997 and spawned a best-selling series.